News

SGPC on defensive after installing ACs inside Golden Temple

News Source: www.thaindian.com
Amritsar, May 29 (IANS) Pushed on the back-foot, the Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) is defending its decision to provide air-conditioned comfort in the holiest of Sikh shrines - the Harmandar Sahib, popularly called the Golden Temple, here. The SGPC - the mini-parliament of Sikh religion that manages gurudwaras in Punjab - has got two four-tonne air-conditioners installed inside the sanctum sanctorum this week for the comfort of millions of devotees who come here. However, conservationists and religious leaders have objected to the move.


Though the air-conditioning unit itself is installed just outside the gold-sheeted building, the pillar-type ACs have been installed where the living Sikh guru - Granth Sahib (the holy book of Sikhs) - is kept.

“The raagis (hymn singers) complained of sweltering heat and humidity inside the shrine during peak summer months when they performed for three to four hours. That’s why we installed these. We have taken the opinion of conservation experts,” SGPC president Avtar Singh Makkar said.

The controversy over installation of the ACs inside the sanctum sanctorum started in May last year when Surinder Kaur Badal, wife of Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal, first moved the proposal.

The SGPC and Makkar, who are dominated by the ruling Akali Dal leadership, especially the Badal family, got down to getting the ACs installed despite stiff opposition from Sikh scholars, conservationists, religious leaders and others.

“This move is not appropriate. There is no need for the ACs inside the holy shrine. It is an ill-conceived idea,” former SGPC secretary Manjit Singh Calcutta said.

Makkar defended the decision saying it was not done at the behest of Surinder Kaur.

Several conservationists, including Gurmit Rai, have objected to the installation of the ACs, saying that these will damage the building that is over 400 years old.

“This will cause colossal structural damage to the building which is made of burnt bricks and lime mortar. The building is supposed to keep heat away,” a noted Sikh scholar told IANS on condition of anonymity.

Conservationists say the paintings and other age-old decorations inside the sanctum sanctorum will be damaged by the temperature changes because of the ACs.

The Harmandar Sahib was built by fifth Sikh guru Arjan Dev. Its foundation was laid by famous Muslim saint Mian Mir in January 1589. The Adi Granth - a holy scripture of the Sikhs, was installed here by the guru in 1604.

Though many Sikh gurudwaras now have ACs, Sikh scholars and conservationists say the religious sanctity of the Golden Temple should have been maintained by not installing the ACs since it is a heritage building.

“Devotees spend just a couple of minutes inside the shrine. The raagis should not look for comfort. It’s a privilege for them to be performing at this holy shrine. The SGPC is not justified in this action,” said local shopkeeper Balbir Singh.

Technology and Heritage

I agree with projectnaad. Airconditioning will help the structure and fine art by reducing the wide fluctuations in daily temperatures and humidity. Global warming and a tremendous increase in the number of Devotees had certainly changed todays environment for the worse. In hot summer and humid monhs of AUgust and September and on holidays and gurupurabs when thousands of devoteees visit Harmandir Sahib it becomes uncomfortable and many people avoid going to the Golden Temple on these busy days. Handicapped and old people should have a preferred access. Big screens should display the live keertan on a closed circuit at various places like teh Langar Hall, Sarai, and Parikrama. Nano mist fans should be considered along the bridge betweenthe Darshani Deori and Harmandir Sahib.

Technology and Heritage

There is nothing wrong per se with the introduction of comfort technologies which improve the living and working conditions of sevadar and raagis. There was a time when there was no electricity in Harmander Sahib. There was a time when it was considered sacriligeous to create a copy of the Guru Granth Sahib using a printing machine. Only handwritten copies of the Guru Granth Sahib were allowed. In addition, today there is a machine which makes the millions of rotis every month in the langar hall and there is a world class filteration system which keeps the sarvor water clean. So long as the up most consideration has been given for preserving the Architectural heritage, then I can't see any logical reason for not installing AC. www.projectnaad.com

Hundreds of years, now

ssk's picture
Hundreds of years, now suddenly its too hot? Is it really worth risking damaging the structure? It surely is not.

We MUST be aware of our Guru's Haters (RSS)

"Golden Temple should have been maintained by not installing the ACs since it is a heritage building." ============================================================== Our Ragi brothers are looking for Air Conditioned Comfort, and we can understand. Our beloved Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji was put on a sheet of red hot metal and hot sand was poured over him, just think of the severe pain he endured .we must always be reminded of this when ever we experience the heat in the temple. We are spoiled with the modern comfort of Air Conditioning.. and that includes me. For all you know there are wicked people who instigated this so that the difference in temperatures and humidity over an extended period of time could destroy the structure of the building. We must bring in a team of Pious Sikh Structural Engineers to conduct an in dept study and report to the World Wide Sangat. This is our Gurus Ji's building and we must put our heads together politics aside and do what’s best for Sri Harmindar Sahib Ji. Guru Ji will bless us. Ben Laden evil advisors knew how to destroy the two towers of the World Trade Center in New York City, by crashing two passenger jet air crafts above the 80th floor of the towers releasing thousands of gallons of jet fuel creating an inferno and killing over 3000 innocent people. The same is probably true here given our past experience of 1984. We must investigate it with an open heart and mind for the good of humanity. ============================================================== Our enemy the RSS leaders worship Swami Vivekananda. In a book entitled “Thoughts of Power” pg 8 text 25 Vivekananda writes Quote “Do even EVIL like a man! Be WICKED, if you must, on a GREAT scale!” Vivekananda was a meat eating Brahmin who worshipped Goddess Kali as the Supreme Lord. And a first class Manmukh.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Email Lists

SikhNet.com Updates Daily Sikh News Daily Hukamnama Unsubscribe